Super Bowl Predictions
I hope I don't regret this after the Wild Card round...
Parker Blackwell
1/9/2026
I’ve said it a few times already, but I’ll say it again before putting anything in writing: this playoff field feels as wide open as I can remember. That’s what makes predictions this year so dangerous — and also so much fun. These could look genius in a month or completely ridiculous by next weekend. But that’s the point. So here we go!
In the AFC, as much as it pains me to even type this out, I think the team that comes out on top is the Buffalo Bills. I don’t like it, I’m not rooting for it, but I can’t shake the feeling. They feel desperate in a very real way. This feels like a team that knows its window is almost completely closed, and sometimes that kind of urgency is exactly what pushes you over the hump.
There are a few reasons this year feels different for them. For one, Josh Allen doesn’t have to go through the one guy who’s blocked him year after year, Patrick Mahomes. That alone changes the entire landscape of the AFC. He also doesn’t have to deal with Lamar Jackson, by-the-way. When you remove those two obstacles, the path suddenly looks very real.
I went back and forth a lot on this. I could absolutely make the case for Houston. I could also make the case for New England. Both are playing great football, and neither would surprise me at all. But in the end, experience is what led me to my conclusion. Buffalo has been here before. They’ve been close before. And sometimes that heartbreak piles up until it finally turns into a breakthrough. I think this might be that year — at least in the AFC.
Over in the NFC, I’m sticking with the San Francisco 49ers, who were my pick to win the super bowl before the season began. Their defense hasn’t quite been as dominant as we expected coming into the season, but they’ve been playing their best football in the second half of the year, and that matters. This team has been knocking on the door for a while now, and it feels like they understand exactly what it takes to survive January football.
Brock Purdy has looked every bit like the franchise guy they believed he could be of late. He’s calm, decisive, and playing with real confidence. And there’s something poetic about the idea of another Super Bowl where the stadium hosting ends up hosting its own team. It just feels like one of those years where experience and timing line up perfectly.
So that gives us a Bills–49ers Super Bowl. And as much as I can talk myself into Buffalo getting to that stage, I can’t pick them to actually win it all. Maybe it’s irrational. Maybe it’s unfair. But they’ve never won a Super Bowl, and there’s something about that franchise that always seems to find a way to fall short at the very end. Call it a curse, call it bad luck, call it whatever you want — I just don’t trust them to finish the job.
That’s why my Super Bowl champion is the 49ers. They feel steadier. More complete. More comfortable on that stage. And when it comes down to one game, that stuff matters.
And yes, before anyone jumps on me — both of these teams could lose in the first round. That wouldn’t even shock me. But that’s what makes this year so exciting. There are no real favorites. No dominant juggernaut. Just a wide-open playoff where anything can happen.
And honestly? That’s the best kind of NFL postseason there is.